Pinderfields Hospital tree felling plan scaled back after claims of ‘drastic action’

Watch more of our videos on ShotsTV.com 
and on Freeview 262 or Freely 565
Visit Shots! now
Plans to fell trees in the grounds of a hospital have been scaled back after health chiefs were accused of an ‘overly cautious’ approach to health and safety.

Wakefield Council has granted permission for 14 trees to be chopped down and replaced at Pinderfields Hospital.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Pruning of a number of other protected trees will also be carried out to make them safe.

But planning officers have ordered that three trees earmarked for the chop be saved as there is “no justification” for them being destroyed.

Plans to fell trees in the grounds of Pinderfields Hospital have been scaled back after health chiefs were accused of an 'overly cautious' approach to health and safety.Plans to fell trees in the grounds of Pinderfields Hospital have been scaled back after health chiefs were accused of an 'overly cautious' approach to health and safety.
Plans to fell trees in the grounds of Pinderfields Hospital have been scaled back after health chiefs were accused of an 'overly cautious' approach to health and safety.

The local authority made a ‘split decision’ after the hospital submitted a request to remove or make safe 24 protected trees.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Species include ash, lime, oak, sycamore willow, horse chestnut and maple.

The application led to an objection from a member of the public who called for some trees to be saved.

The objection refers to the controversy involving Sheffield City Council, where thousands of trees were felled as part of a £2.2bn street improvement project, sparking public anger and protests.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad
Plans to fell trees in the grounds of Pinderfields Hospital have been scaled back after health chiefs were accused of an 'overly cautious' approach to health and safety.Plans to fell trees in the grounds of Pinderfields Hospital have been scaled back after health chiefs were accused of an 'overly cautious' approach to health and safety.
Plans to fell trees in the grounds of Pinderfields Hospital have been scaled back after health chiefs were accused of an 'overly cautious' approach to health and safety.

It states: “It seems to me to be an overly cautious approach to health and safety and also a drastic action to fell this many trees and do so much work on other trees.

“I would request that an independent tree expert assesses these trees.

“There have been cases in the past, most notably the Sheffield tree scandal, when experts have recommended tree removal only for other experts to examine the trees and disagree with the removal plans.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

The objector adds: “Hospitals can also be very stressful places. Trees are very good for people’s wellbeing.

“There is also a lot of value from these trees to the wider area.

“Recently trees have been felled on Newton Bar, Pinderfields Hospital roundabout and throughout City Fields.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

“I therefore urge you to only remove these trees if absolutely necessary, from a safety point of view and to require a tree planting plan if felling is the only option.”

Officers agreed that it was “necessary/agreeable” to fell 14 trees but have ordered the planting of replacement trees by the end of March.

But they said there was “no justification” to fell a sycamore and two ash trees near to the hospital.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Permission was also refused to carry out pruning work on two other trees.

The hospital made the application following after a tree health assessment survey was carried out by an arborist in August 21.

His report states: “All trees were inspected from ground level only and all comments and recommendations made have taken into account the location of each tree, their surroundings and their likely impact on persons or property.”