Parents raised concerns that PE classes for pupils at Featherstone Academy were being switched for union in a break with tradition opposed by nearly 2,500 people who signed a petition, set up by parent Andrew Bell.
Featherstone Rovers, which provides rugby league training at the school, held talks with the school last week to try to resolve the dispute.
But a spokesman for the club said: "No decision has been made and further talks will be held."
After the petition gathered momentum, Featherstone’s headteacher, Wesley Bush, said there were no plans to discontinue rugby league and the school intended to provide both codes.
The Express has approached Featherstone Academy for comment on the ongoing talks.