Dr's Casebook by Dr Keith Souter: Would you want to win an Olympic medal?

After all that training it would be natural to covet an Olympic medalplaceholder image
After all that training it would be natural to covet an Olympic medal

The Winter Olympics are in full swing and after four years of training the athletes are in the hunt for medals of any colour.

Every competitor should be proud to be an Olympian, having the honour of representing their country and hopefully adding to the tally of medals. But what a coveted prize an actual Olympic medal must be, and what a disappointment if one is pipped at the post to miss out. It is human nature in such circumstances to feel envious of those who have gained one.

Elite athletes seem able to deal with disappointment. The Olympics seems to bring out the best in people and you see it again and again where competitors are genuinely happy for their opponent’s success.

Yet envy is a curious thing. You can see it in young children, some of whom always seem to want the toy that another child has, and in teenagers who want to have the same fashion accessories, tablet or smartphone as their peers.

You can see envy in children when new toys appearplaceholder image
You can see envy in children when new toys appear

The French philosopher Rene Girard first described the reason that people get envious in the 1960s. He called it ‘mimetic desire'. Effectively, we borrow our desires from other people.

Mimetic desire comes about because we unconsciously rate something’s worth in terms of its value, its usefulness and also in terms of how much other people want it. I was interested to read that this year’s Olympic medals of all three colours are the most valuable ever, because gold and silver costs have soared. That is monetary value, but I suspect that most medal winners would consider the prestige and honour of being a medalist as being the most important thing.

Yet mimetic interest can spread to produce the flavour of the month or the latest craze. Equally, the bubble can burst when the mimetic desire is lost and yesterday’s craze seems irrelevant.

A study from Paris, using MRI brain scans studied over a hundred people between the ages of 18 and 39. They were shown videos of a whole range of things, but in different contexts. Some were merely shown lying on a table, while others had the same object lying on the table, but with a hand reaching for it. They had to rate each videoed object using a ‘desirability score’ from 1 to 10.

Two main brain areas became active as they watched. The first was the mirror neurone system (MNS), which activates when an individual makes a movement or sees someone else move. This helps us to understand the actions of others. The second area was the brain valuation system (BVS), which we use to value things. They also found that the two areas seem to be linked. When an object was seen being reached for, both the MNS and the BVS areas became activated. Effectively, when something is seen to be desired, it triggers off that envy feeling in the brain. It would be interesting to see if those brain centres become active when athletes see those medals being put around opponents’ necks.

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1852
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice