Castleford Tigers penned back in second half in disappointing defeat to York
After the encouragement of recent weeks Castleford Tigers turned in a hugely disappointing display as they were beaten on home soil by York Knights.
Ryan Carr’s men were not lacking in effort, but were made to pay for making too many errors, particularly in the first 25 minutes of the second half, as they saw a 10-6 half-time lead turn into a 20-14 defeat to opponents who had only previously won three games since coming into Super League.
Castleford looked in control in the first half and should have held more than a four-point advantage after a 65 per cent share of possession and some good field positions that were wasted with a lack of sharpness.
But they were penned into their own half for long periods in the second half and despite defending stoutly at times they were eventually undone in conceding three tries before a late rally almost pulled off a comeback.


In the end the Tigers could perhaps count themselves unlucky not to snatch something from the game as they came up with a third try six minutes from time then came within inches of another.
Jason Qareqare – who had earlier scored his 13th try of the season – headed for the corner only for the ball to come out of his hand as he dived for the line. It was a high tackle that had stopped him, but although video referee Liam Rush agreed there had been foul play he stopped short of awarding a penalty try that would have seen the scores tied up going into the last minute.
With Cas then unable to score from the following set their defeat was confirmed and – whatever anyone thought of the big late decision and a few others over the course of the match – even the most diehard of fans could not really have any complaints about losing, so poor had they been at times.
Initially the Tigers looked to be following on from their victory over Toulouse the previous week as they opened the scoring in the eighth minute with winger Semi Valemei – back in the side after suspension – going over after Louis Senior has patted down Tom Weaver's high kick to the corner.


Weaver was unable to convert and York hit back through Cody Hunter who took advantage of some unconvincing tackling to score after collecting a pass from former Tigers star Paul McShane. With Hunter tagging on the extras the visitors were ahead.
York were reduced to 12 men for 10 minutes when another of their ex-Cas contingent, Sam Wood, was yellow carded for what looked a crusher tackle on Qareqare.
The Tigers winger was able to continue after having treatment and made the Knights pay when he raced over for a try while York were still a man down, collecting a looping pass from Phoenix Laulu-Togaga’e to score in the corner.
Weaver added a fine touchline conversion, but it remained 10-6 until the break with further home pressure coming to nothing.


What followed at the start of the second half was horrific from a home side point of view.
They were immediately put under pressure with a goal-line drop-out forced. After surviving the following set it was soon back on the defensive and attempts to get down the other end were thwarted when successive sets ended with dreadful plays on the last tackle, running it twice to no effect and Weaver putting a relieving kick straight into touch.
When a last tackle kick was finally made home fans responded with a sarcastic cheer, but this was followed by conceding a penalty for tackle interference and the team was back near their on line again.
The Tigers did show some backbone with some good defending, surviving back to back drop-outs, but mistakes with the ball in hand continued to dog them and eventually the defence cracked with Oli Field going over for a try that went unconverted.


It was still one-way traffic with no relief for the hosts and after referee Ryan Cox missed a knock-on in the build-up Field’s offload sent David Nofoaluma over to put York ahead.
PLT tried his best to get Cas going with some darting runs that took some holding and they looked to be back in it when their opponents were penalised by rookie referee Cox – a late deputy for the injured James Vella – deep in their own half for dropping the ball.
But a successful captain’s challenge gave the Knights a penalty for interference and they marched upfield with Scott Galeano outjumping Qareqare to collect McShane’s high kick for another try.
To Castleford’s credit they quickly hit back as they regained possession and an off the cuff kick to the corner by Daejarn Asi was well collected by Valemei for his second try.
Weaver was unable to convert from the touchline, leaving the home team six points behind, but there was more drama to come. The referee wrongly ruled a knock-on against Renouf Atoni after he had threatened following more good work by PLT and a captain’s challenge overturned the decision to give Cas more hope.
This turned to cheers when Qareqare headed for the line and jeers with the high tackle not punished by a penalty try that would have given Weaver a simple chance to level the scores with the kick.
York held on in a thrilling finish which was not in keeping with what had been a largely poor contest.
