"I've eaten at 120 fish and chip shops across the UK - and this Wakefield chippy is one of the best"
Stephen Peel, 62, has been eating at two fish and chip shops a week for the last 15 month in his quest to find the nation's best chippies.
He started on his 'Chippy Tour' to celebrate the iconic meal which he says the country is in danger of losing as many are being forced to close due to high costs.
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide AdOn his tour Stephen has been rating chippies out of five with the whole experience including customer service, cleanliness, presentation, alongside the grub, going under scrutiny.


Stephen said: "I've tried quite a lot of chippies so far on this journey but it has never gotten old - I still look forward to eating them every single time.
"I just love a good old traditional fish and chips - there is nothing that beats it for me."
The chippies Stephen reviews he rates out of five - which he says keeps the process "nice and simple".
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide AdThough he doesn't just rate the food, the shop itself, the customer service, the cleanliness, accessibility, and the presentation are also built into the score.


He said: "There is a lot that goes into getting a five star review - I also put a lot of pride into giving them.
"All aspects of the experience affect the score - for instance how friendly the staff are as for me manners are important.
"How the shop is presented is also something I look out for too as I want to feel comfortable and welcome when I'm inside.
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide Ad"Also those who sell other meals like kebabs and pizzas for instance alongside the chippy if the love for fish and chips doesn't come first then it may affect the score.


"I'm sharing the joy and the history of these iconic places - I want to do it right."
Stephen says to score a five it has to be "that good" people won't be disappointed if they travel to visit it".
The reviewer has said the chippy prices vary up and down the country.
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide AdHe said: On average nationwide it cost around £10 for an average meal - up north it is a little bit cheaper as you normally pay £8 in my experience.
"But further down south you are looking to pay double the northern price."
Stephen only started the journey in February last year after his wife, Susan, barber's shop was forced to close after being "drowned out" by newer businesses.
Stephen, of Warrington, said: "It got me thinking, this surely can't be the only business being affected.
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide Ad"Fish and chips has always been my favourite since I was a lad.
"Soon enough I found out that their numbers had decreased massively over the last 30 years from 30,000 to around 10,000.
"It has become increasingly difficult for them to stay open with the raising prices.
"So I started The Chippy Tour to celebrate the iconic dish and to try my best to keep the buzz of having a chippy alive."
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide AdDescribing the perfect portion he said: "There is a freshness to the fish with no discolouration - for me it doesn't matter if it is cod or haddock.
"I have no preference on the colour of the batter but as along as it isn't soggy underneath you are all good.
"It has to look fresh and clean - when you break open the batter there should be a sweet earthy smell."
"For the chips you are looking for the light golden colour.
"They need to be a little plump while crispy on the outside but not too firm in the middle but also not too overly soft - you are looking for the sweet spot."
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide Ad"Finally I prefer it to cooked in beef dripping and not seeded oil - the flavours are much better this way."
He said the favourite condiments to pair with it are Sarsons vinegar and a curry sauce.
Stephen has said that so far on his quest there have been quite a few locations that have stood out.
But he said the most memorable so far was George A. Green Fisheries in Wakefield.
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide AdHe said: "It has to go down as one of my all-time favourites—great food at great prices.
"Encased within what resembles a crunchy protective shell was a succulent, fresh fillet of haddock.
"The fishcake, or Yorkshire fishcake, consisted of two tender slices of potato sandwiching delicious shredded fresh fish, once again enveloped in that crispy dark batter, cooked in beef dripping.
"Given the appeal of the batter and beef dripping, I couldn’t resist ordering a portion of scraps too.
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide Ad"The potato scallops and the chips were equally delightful, with the chips boasting a buttery interior and a crispy exterior.
"The staff were pleasant and polite, contributing to the friendly atmosphere.
"The shop itself is clean and tidy, housed in a stand-alone building with tables and benches outside, and a large, free private car park at the rear."
His other favourites include Wee Hurrie in Troon, Scotland which he said was in an "incredible location right on a fishing harbour, so everything came out as fresh as could be".
Advertisement
Hide AdAdvertisement
Hide AdHe also enjoyed Hooked@31 Fishguard, in South Wales, which he said was "incredible" as not only was the food "fantastic" but it was just a "short trip" to the harbour where you could enjoy it.
Stephen one day hopes he would be able to try all of what the UK has to offer.
He said: "Wouldn't that be wonderful if I could.
"I hope people continue to enjoy this lovely dish."
Stephens top five chippies:
1st Place - Green Lane Chippy - Leigh, Lancashire
2nd Place - The Old Forge Cafe - Bugle, Cornwall
3rd Place - Charlie's of Mobberley - Mobberley, Cheshire
4th Place - George A. Green Fisheries - Wakefield
5th Place - Hennighan's, Machynlleth, Wales
Comment Guidelines
National World encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.